My Theory on Tauriel, Kili, and Legolas | My Renaissance
This strain ends up finally cracking when Thranduil banishes Tauriel, whom Legolas cares for and has a strong friendship/relationship with. The crux of that uncle-nephew relationship lies within this moment. The young dwarves Arrival of the Eagles (BotFA) BotFA (Battle ends). Also Kili dies (spoiler) at the end of the series, as a result we can safely on the dwarves and maybe help them reconsider their relationship, they may . There is a part in BotFA when Legolas watches Tauriel speaking with.
In these two instances, despite the grand scale of the conflicts, our attention is solely on the duel; but by integrating this set-piece with the rest of the action, creates a sense of cohesion and a balance to the sub-narrative of the battle. Why would Thorin send his nephews to scout the area while he remained behind?
By shifting this scene to the barren slopes of Ravenhill, Jackson may have wanted to experiment with the thriller aspects of the story: Those aware of the book would have realised the decision to send the 2 nephews to scout the area would eventually lead to their deaths. In the book, Thorin is mortally wounded by Bolg.
As a result, Fili and Kili rush to his aid which is ultimately the cause of their deaths. The crux of that uncle-nephew relationship lies within this moment. The young dwarves sacrificing themselves for their father figure. Peter Jackson was certainly on the right track when he established and worked on the relationship between Thorin and Kili — right up to the touching moment between the two before they charge out of the gate of Erebor.
This compels me to ask the next question … Why the lack of substantial violence? I know this was aimed at a PG audience, but intense situations need to be dealt with the right amount of gravitas. Disposing of your characters by failing to do so in a believable manner, takes away all the suspense and emotional connection of that moment.
The Problematic Climax of ‘The Battle of the Five Armies’ | A Tolkienist's Perspective
He simply reacts and jolts. No trace of blood, nothing.
Unfortunately, this makes things superficial. After all, in the book it is the main location from which the orcs muster and begin their march towards Erebor — led by their leader, Bolg. We are also introduced to new creatures in Middle-earth — giant bats more on these below. The threat posed to the Elves, Dwarves and Men by another looming army is a fantastic way in raising the stakes for our characters even higher.
Yet, no sooner has the Gundabad army arrived on the field of battle than it is instantly overcome. What would have been the point of showing us the march of this army, its constant threat, and then take all that away in the blink of an eye? Perhaps Jackson wanted to avoid a second, renewed attack by another army — thereby reducing the length of the battle; but this has resulted in an abrupt and unbalanced conclusion to the conflict.
Bringing the two orc contingents together and attacking at once would have avoided such a jarring narrative resolution. Admittedly, in The Return of the King and two instances in The Hobbit book versionsthe Eagles play an important part.
First, I will start with Tauriel and Kili.
The Problematic Climax of ‘The Battle of the Five Armies’
I do agree with what others are saying about the idea of them as a couple being a bit awkward. She is an immortal elf and he is a dwarf, who would have eventually died anyway if he survived at the end of the third film. If Tauriel visited Kili fairly often, I could see some sort of romance forming between the two in that time period. Also, Tauriel is around years old since it appears that she was taken in by Thranduil as presumably a child when her parents died years prior to the events in The Hobbit.
It may be that she has never experienced romance up until her meeting with Kili, so even though she has had time to acquire a lot of knowledge and skill in healing and fighting, she is still quite new to love.
The fact that romance existed between an elf and a dwarf may also stem from how young they were. He is Aragon, son of Arathorn. You owe him your allegiance. Although in the books, there is already a good explanation for how Legolas previously met Aragon. However, this was dropped or not mentioned during the whole run of the LOTR trilogy. In the books, Gandalf sent Aragon to track down Gollum and hand him over to the elves of Thranduil.
Aragon eventually found him and Mirkwood was given the responsibility to watch over Gollum; however, he escaped and it is for that reason Legolas was sent to Rivendell by Thranduil himself. This could perfectly explain how Aragon could have previously met Legolas, who was probably one of the elves who watched over Gollum.
But this is not mentioned within Fellowship of the Ring, and thus, Jackson had to create a new reason for how Legolas knew of Aragon's identity as the rightful king of Gondor. Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring by J. Tolkien Pages " All sat silent for a while, until at length, Boromir spoke. Small, but great in mischief.
What became of him? To what doom did you put him? There is no doubt that he was tormented, and the fear of Sauron lies black on his heart.5 Signs to Leave a Relationship
Still, I for one am glad that he is safely kept by the watchful Elves of Mirkwood. His malice is great and gives him strength hardly to be believed in one so lean and withered.
He could work much mischief still, if he were free. And I do not doubt that he was allowed to leave Mordor on some evil errand.
They are not good, but only here have I learned how evil they may seem to this company.